Naoto Shirogane نوع شخصية MBTI
شخصية
"ما نوع الشخصية Naoto Shirogane؟ Naoto Shirogane هو نوع INTJ في mbti ، 5w4 - sp/so - 514 في enneagram ، RCOAI في Big 5 ، LII في Socionics."
I don't quite get the ISTP votes, but I'm willing to be convinced. Nevertheless, I think there's a much stronger case for INTJ, which I'll detail here. For one, there's the matter of Se; why auxiliary Se? I've not seen any decent explanations for her Se usage - I've seen a few people saying "her Se is too high to be an INTJ" without elaborating on what Se usage they are perceiving, and the few people I've seen who have tried to explain it have talked in overly broad terms that make it impossible to verify or falsify anything being claimed. I'd expect there to be more examples of Se usage for someone to be typed as a high Se user, but I can neither think of any such examples, nor have any been provided. ISTP is not a reasonable typing until some measure of meaningfully high Se usage can be established. Secondly, there's the matter of Te versus Ti. Te usage in action often implies a deductive process; a Te user will look to attain and examine tangible evidence, and then derive plausible conclusions from the evidence collected. Ti usage in action, on the other hand, often implies an inductive process; a Ti user will willingly derive conclusions from limited context first, then gradually cross off those conclusions over time by process of elimination. In a simplified sense, you could say that a Te user starts with evidence then forms a conclusion, while a Ti user starts with the conclusions then narrows them down with evidence. With this dichotomy in mind, I think it's incredibly clear that Naoto is a Te user; her process is deductive, not inductive, and focused on examination of evidence prior to formation of conclusions. For an example of what I mean, take the scene where Naoto is attempting to discern who Nanako's kidnapper was. At no point does Naoto ever make a claim in this scene that she cannot clearly prove and provide watertight backing for - she doesn't even imply that Nanako's kidnapper could've been someone Nanako knew until she found proof that: 1: Nanako opened the door for the kidnapper. 2: Nanako only opens doors for people she knows. 3: Ergo, the kidnapper was someone Nanako knows. The same thing applies to every other claim she makes, both in this scene and in every other investigation she conducts. At no point (to my memory, at least) does she start off with plausible conclusions and work her way backwards; she simply doesn't acknowledge the conclusion until it is proven. This is one of the key ways of discerning Te versus Ti, and is even quite a prevalent pattern if you look at other examples of detectives in fiction. With both of these in mind, I don't believe the Ti-Se-Ni-Fe function stack fits her at all. She both shows a strong preference for Te over Ti, and does not possess high Se.
سيرة شخصية
Naoto Shirogane is a playable character from Persona 4. A first year student at Yasogami High School who works as a detective at the police departament, Naoto is known as the "Detective Prince", famous for her high intelligence and pragmatic approach. She arrives in Inaba with a goal to solve the on-going serial murder case and often encounters the Investigation Team, getting in their way which causes her to appear arrogant. After joining the team, she becomes the group's brain. Naoto exhibits a very serious demeanor, even getting called a "2000-iq killjoy detective". She treats her detective work very professionally and passionately, striving to become her ideal image of a detective. This however causes her to suppress her true self in order to fit that image and receive recognition.
