Frank Castle "The Punisher" tipe kepribadian MBTI
Kepribadian
"Jenis kepribadian apa itu Frank Castle "The Punisher"? Frank Castle "The Punisher" adalah tipe kepribadian ISTJ di mbti, 8w9 - - 864 di enneagram, RLOEN dalam Big 5, LSI dalam socionics."
Since alignments came back I see Frank as Neutral Evil. The version I'm most familiar with and like the best is Ennis's portrayal of him in MAX. That Frank does not have a strict code of ethics beyond not murdering innocents or cops. He enjoys killing and views himself as a force of murderous rage that knows no mercy, even to those who might sincerely be apologetic. His bloodlust is not confined to people who have wronged him personally, just those who get in his way or who he deems as unworthy of life. There's a point in MAX where he has dreams of indiscriminate murder, once all the people who he deems as deserving - those who could fight back - are gone, he turns his rage to the gawking masses - "If my world ends, so does yours." It was never about justice. He doesn't pretend otherwise. His actions are not prosocial and he holds no pretense that the world would be a better place if more people adopted his worldview. He does not uphold the law or any sort of internal view of order. Dedicating yourself to murder purely for the catharsis it brings is evil, at least by D&D standards, even if the people you're hunting happen to be criminals. I really hate when Frank is written to be someone who sees himself as good or doesn't understand why other people view him as a bad guy, it's a fundemental misunderstanding of the character to me. I don't think Frank should ever be written as someone who believes himself to be in the right. Ennis had it right when he viewed him as a serial killer who just picks other bad guys as his targets. Ennis is also one of the few writers to point out that it wasn't just the men who murdered his family that helped create the Punisher, it was the government who were happy to have people like him in Vietnam murdering essentially innocent people. When the Netflix show tried to do this, it ended up being more of a Bourne/Clancy novel affair with Frank going up against the 'corrupt' element of the state department, which obviously isn't reflective of the system as a whole. As an aside, Marvel have made it pretty clear that they want to erase the character entirely with that awful run by Jason Aaron, in which Frank's wife is literally brought back to life in order to have some girlboss moment of divorcing him officially, taking his money and driving off, but strangely weren't brave enough to examine the actual politics behind the character and exactly why his symbol has been used the way it has in real life. No cop or soldier with a Punisher symbol on their uniform, gun or vehicle is ever going to read that comic, or care about it at all, so it came off as completely toothless. As for typology, I think it's pretty clear Frank is an ISTJ. If he's an ISTP, I don't see any indication of Ti, Fe or Ni. He repeats the same methods that he was taught in the military, he views this war as no different than Vietnam. Unlike Batman, there's no Ni fixation on symbology - where Bruce Wayne tries to make himself something more than human, an abstraction to prey on the superstitions of his enemies, The Punisher is very much human, just not one you can stop. He doesn't need to be good at everything like Batman, his methods are tried and true. Pure Si. For enneagram, 8 doesn't make sense to me. Frank doesn't try to assert his independence and he isn't expressing a desire for control. He's extremely *out* of control and he knows it. He couldn't stop being the Punisher if he wanted to. He's repeating the same day over and over and he doesn't care because it's the only thing that makes sense to him.
Biografi
The Punisher (Francis "Frank" Castle, born Castiglione) is a fictional character appearing in American comic books published by Marvel Comics. The character was created by writer Gerry Conway and artists John Romita Sr. and Ross Andru, with publisher Stan Lee green-lighting the name. The Punisher made his first appearance in The Amazing Spider-Man #129 (cover-dated February 1974).
Kepribadian correlate
Peter Parker “Spider-Man”
Wade Wilson “Deadpool”
Tony Stark “Iron Man”
Doctor Doom
James Howlett “Wolverine”
Loki
Matt Murdock “Daredevil”
Wanda Maximoff “Scarlet Witch”
