Joy MBTI 성격 유형
인격
"Joy은 어떤 성격 유형입니까? Joy은 mbti의 ENFJ 성격 유형입니다. enneagram의 7w6 - so/sx - 712, big 5의 SCOAI, socionics의 ESE입니다."
This debate is really interesting tbh. I haven't watched the movie for so long but I'll analyse some quotes I found and see what I can make of the functions. "Anger, unload the daydreams. I've ordered extra incase things get slow in class." Looks more Ni to me. Preparing for a possible future unwravelling. " Do you ever look at someone and wonder, what is going on inside their head?" This is more of a stereotype for me but I see ENFJs as more curious about how other people's psychology works than an ESFJ would. Also, ESFJs are Ni blind and I struggle to see many ESFJs really dive into this kind of thing. Ni typically likes to solve this kind of problem more often. "You remember how she used to stick her tongue out when she was colouring? I could listen to her stories, all day. I just wanted Riley to be happy..." OK this sounds like more of an Si thing, whereas ENFJs are blind with Si and recalling memories, though of course not all ENFJS are inherently bad at memory recall. However, I see ENFJs (or people with bad memory in general, like me lol) would be more likely to remember past memories that they really vibed with, and ENFJs tend to love other people recalling stories. This is why ENFJs and INFPs are said to be such a good match. Also, Riley sticking her tongue out suggests she was really enjoying herself and being happy, which is what any Fe dom desires the most. Finally, this might not be a valid argument but Joy doesn't recall small details of the memory, but then again she might not have felt the need to. Honestly this quote could work for either argument, but it's not a clear ESFJ win. "Oh, it's that time in the twisty tree, remember? The hockey team showed up and Mom and Dad were there cheering. Look at her, having fun and laughing. It's my favorite. " Same arguments for the last memory recall quote I just analysed. Again, it's not too focused on the details. " Dad : [Trying to feed Riley broccoli] Here we go. All right, open. Joy : Hmm... this looks new. " So we know Si tends to be less comfortable with change. I'd have to actually watch this scene to look at her tone of voice and body language etc but this doesn't show she's too stressed out by it so I lean more towards ENFJ for this one. " Hey, look! The Golden Gate Bridge! Isn't that great? It's not made out of solid gold like we thought, which is kind of a disappointment, but still! " Possible Se child again. She also shows disappointment of her idea of it being made of gold as Ni, but she remains optimistic about it, and also once again shows she's better at handling change than an Si user probably would. Also, ENFJs tend to expect or see things quite literally, but I'm not sure how that would compare to the ESFJ perspective. "[Joy and Bing Bong have fallen into the Memory Dump and are stuck down there, doomed to be forgotten forever. Joy tried fruitlessly to climb up the piles of old memories to get out] " This could be a more weaker argument for a weak Ne and just attempting a single obvious solution, using Se. The rest of the scene sounds like Joy is going a bit into her INFP shadow, remeniscing of the good moments of the past. It's what an ENFJ would do when they struggle to use several of their usual conscious functions. I'd say an ESFJ with child Ne would be able to come up with other ideas of getting out. It's really interesting to read this quote in particular because I see myself getting kinda addicted to sad memories when I am sad sometimes. I'm not sure why that happens lol. " [Joy makes Riley laugh for the first time] Joy : [voiceover] It was amazing! Just Riley and me, forever. [Riley suddenly starts crying] Joy : [voiceover] Um, for thirty-three seconds. " This could be an argument for Si actually. Not sure how else she would remember the exact number of seconds. "[Joy begins the new day by waking up all the emotions with an accordion] " Super stereotyping but this sounds like an argument against Si, loosely speaking. "Joy : Okay, first day of school! Very, very exciting! I was up late last night figuring out a new plan. Here it is. [Fear walks by writing on a notepad] Joy : Fear! I need a list of all the possible negative outcomes on the first day at a new school." Again, she's excited by new. I think Si would be a lot more cautious or nervous about it. Also, she's future planning which is another Ni argument. She's asking someone else (Fear) to basically use his Ne (icr where his Ne is tho) because her Ne isn't as strong. " Disgust : Hey, guys? What's pub-er-ty? Joy : I don't know. It's probably not important. " Not sure what this could be an argument for. All I know is I myself sometimes dismiss something as probably not important. Could be an inferior Ti thing and go either way for both types. More quotes in comments...
전기
Joy's goal has always been to make sure Riley stays happy. She is lighthearted, optimistic and determined to find the fun in every situation. Joy sees challenges in Riley's life as opportunities, and the less happy moments as hiccups on the way back to something great. As long as Riley is happy, so is Joy. Her performance model is a star.
