Shuichi Akai / Subaru Okiya (Rye) MBTI性格类型
性格
"Shuichi Akai / Subaru Okiya (Rye)是什么人格？ Shuichi Akai / Subaru Okiya (Rye)是MBTI中的ISTP人格类型，九型中的1w9 - sp/sx - 125，五大类型中的RCOAI，Socionics中LIE类型。"
A fever-SE called curiosity-TI 名为好奇心TI的热病SE --- This comment is divided into three points: I. Akai Shuichi has not demonstrated long-term Ni planning. II. The explanation of "curiosity as a fever" III. Akai Shuichi's lack of Fi in the original work Due to word count limitations, the three points will be split into follow-up comments. --- I. Akai Shuichi has not demonstrated long-term Ni planning. What is long-term Ni planning? It refers to goal-oriented blueprints—breaking down objectives into interlocking steps. I found no evidence in the source material of him having 'a complete, long-term, self-orchestrated PLAN.' Every plan he executes involves collaborators, which fundamentally contradicts Ni-dom (especially Ni-Fi) behavior. 1 The fake-death plan was co-created with Conan. Initially, he didn’t inform the FBI, later altering it mid-course (Spontaneity > Planning). The plan itself emerged randomly from Kir’s accident, capitalizing on timing (Spontaneity > Planning). If he were Planning >Spontaneity, the fake death should’ve been part of a broader long-term plan（first、then、later on)——for finding father. But plan to cut FBI ties undermines this—if the FBI was useless for finding father, why join it? If he could discard his FBI identity so easily, doesn’t that imply joining was itself a impromptu plan? If even joining the FBI was an impromptu plan, it’s hard to believe he had any structured, long-term interlocking-steps strategy for locating his father. Based on this, I ruled out Ni-Te. 2 The plan against Zero was entirely Conan’s. 3 The current Black Tea Meeting was orchestrated by Yusaku. 这篇评论分为三点： 一、 赤井秀一没有展现出长效性NI 二、 关于好奇心与热病的解释 三、 赤井秀一在原作中缺少FI *由于字数限制，三点写不下会拆分在下级评论中 --- 一、赤井秀一没有展现出长效性长期计划NI 什么是长效性的长期计划NI？ 即目标为导向的蓝图，即我要达到一个目标那么我需要分几步走，每一步环环相扣。 我在原作中没有看到这个人物有“一个完整的、长期的、由自己制定的PLAN”。他所有的计划都有合作者，这点与NI1，尤其NI+FI使用者是完全相悖的。 1，假死计划合作者是柯南，且他一开始没打算告诉FBI假死，而在中途篡改计划。这里随机性>计划性。且如果纵观整个假死计划的产生，也是由于水无意外随机产生的计划，属于抓准时机制定计划。还是随机性>计划性。而如果他是计划性>随机性，那么假死计划应该是更长期计划的一部分，即寻找赤井务武长期计划的一部分。但我不认为假死计划中断绝与FBI联系有利于这个长期计划，如果FBI如此对于寻找务武如此无用，他为什么加入FBI？如果加入后可以随意割舍自己这层身份，那是不是正说明加入FBI这个计划也是一个随机计划？如果加入FBI都是一个短期计划，我很难承认他在找他爸这件事上到底有什么环环相扣的长期计划。基于这一点NI-TE被我排除掉了。 2，来叶山面对降谷零追捕他那个计划，全盘都是柯南的计划。 3，现在红茶会内容，工藤优作计划。 II. Explanation of "Curiosity as a Fever" Before elaborating on this statement, let me address another matter first: If we consider only "curiosity and feverishness," you might argue that using a single sentence as evidence seems untenable. In response to this rebuttal, I have two explanations: 1 This particular line was carefully selected as the most representative example. Akai has numerous other Ti-Fe type dialogues, but including them all would make the analysis too lengthy and potentially lose readers' interest. 2 Only judging-axis dominant types (Te/Fi/Ti/Fe dominant) could have curiosity as their primary life motivation. While curiosity can manifest through Ti, it could also appear as Fi-Te/Te-Fi patterns - where love/hate toward an individual (Fi) drives objective inquiry (Te). However, making curiosity the fundamental motivation is only possible for Te-dominant or Fi-dominant types, not INTJs, because Te-Fi/Fi-Te occupy positions 1-4, which constitute the psychological driving force. The INTJ's fundamental motivation comes from the vision provided by Ni-Se - they develop curiosity about something specifically to advance that vision. If an INTJ were to describe their core motivation, it would be closer to "unwavering conviction born of faith." Curiosity = Ti Fever = SE "I need to understand what really happened to my father (Ti). To achieve this, I'm filled with adrenaline, ready to fight to the death (Se)." This demonstrates clear Ti motivation: "I seek - the truth" rather than Ni: "I believe - my father isn't dead." The determination and resolve stemming from Ti is identical to that from Ni. In reality, any function in the 1st position will create the same level of obsession and determination. Those who type Akai as INTJ reduce his Ti and Se to: "He went to America for thrills, joined the FBI out of curiosity, and his 18-year mission was just a series of coincidences." Such statements clearly show limited understanding of cognitive function theory, and even contain implicit disparagement of other types in favor of glorifying INTJs. （See comments for the third point.） 二、 关于好奇心与热病的解释 在解释这句话前我先讨论另一件事： 只考虑“好奇心与热病”或许你会认为只用一句话作为论据站不住脚。 基于这个辩驳我有两点解释： 1 这句话是我经过筛选选出来的最能说明问题的一句，赤井还有很多TI-FE式的台词，如果都写出来篇幅过长可能很多人会丧失兴趣。（字数不足后文见评论）
背景
[Spoilers Below] Shuichi Akai (赤井 秀一 Akai Shūichi?) is an FBI agent and a major figure in the battle against the Black Organization. He once assumed the identity of Dai Moroboshi (諸星 大 Moroboshi Dai?) and infiltrated the Organization, where he was given the codename Rye (ライ Rai?). During this time he made enemies with Gin and became romantically involved with Akemi Miyano. He is the older brother of Shukichi Haneda and Masumi Sera.
相关人物
Shinichi Kudo (Jimmy Kudo) / Conan Edogawa
Conan Edogawa
Ai Haibara / Shiho Miyano (Sherry)
Gin
Ran Mouri (Rachel Moore)
Kaitou Kid
Kogoro Mouri (Richard)
Rei Furuya / Amuro Tooru (Bourbon)
